Skip to main content

Independent. Local. A-Rated.

Stop Overpaying for Insurance. Compare Top-Rated Carriers and Save Today.

Insurance is a necessity in life. You look for it to protect a home, provide safety and comfort to your family. Whether it's renters, auto, commercial, Workers' Comp, or business insurance, First Choice Insurance Agency can provide the coverage you need to protect the investments you value most.

  • Licensed in Florida
  • Independent Agency
  • A+ Rated Carriers
  • Miami-Owned

How It Works

Three steps. We do the shopping. You get the lowest price.

  1. Tell us what you need

    Share a few details — auto, renters, business, life. Takes about 60 seconds online or a quick call.

  2. We shop our network of A-rated carriers

    Progressive, GEICO, Foremost, and more. We compare prices and coverage so you don't have to.

  3. You pick. We've got your back.

    We bring back the best deal. You choose. We're here for claims, renewals, and questions — for life.

What We Offer

Insurance Services

Why First Choice

100% Savings Guarantee

You want the benefits of an insurance plan that will decrease your total payments in the event of an accident. Whatever the reason, each of us seeks the right insurance plan for the right price — and that's exactly what we deliver.

  • Wide variety of A-rated carriers
  • Competitive rates that save you money
  • Personal & commercial coverage
  • Specialized trucking & transportation
  • Expert advisors ready to help

12+

Insurance Products

A+

Rated Carriers

100%

Savings Guarantee

24/7

Claims Support

Our Partners

Trusted Insurance Carriers

We partner with top-rated insurance carriers to bring you the best coverage at competitive prices.

  • Progressive insurance
  • GEICO insurance
  • Foremost insurance
  • National General insurance
  • Bristol West insurance
  • Infinity insurance
  • Amwins insurance
  • Bass Underwriters insurance
  • RPS insurance
  • Ascendant insurance
  • Granada insurance
  • Responsive insurance
  • UAIC insurance
  • USLI insurance
  • Oscar Health insurance
  • Ambetter insurance
  • Cigna insurance
  • UnitedHealthcare insurance
  • AvMed insurance
  • Aetna insurance
  • Molina Healthcare insurance
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield insurance

Client Reviews

What Our Clients Say

5.0

2,125 reviews on Google

  • My wife and I have had the privilege and pleasure of a long lasting relationship with Dianela Martinez and her team at First Insurance for years. The follow up is unwavering. Always a call away, and always calls us for renewals and regularly reviews rates to ensure we are not paying more than we have to. simply the epitome of what you would want to have as "your insurance agent". We've been working with them for years, and will continue to use them, and emphatically endorse them to anyone looking for an insurance agent, if you never want to have to look for another, look no further than Dianela Martinez and First Choice Insurance. Because they really are our 1st choice.

    Jorge Gonzalez (The Mortgage Tech)

    2 weeks ago

  • was able to achieve a great result, along with excellent service. When you call, ask for Gretel; personally, I found her to be very kind and patient, dedicating the time necessary to find me the best possible outcome. If you want to have a positive experience—Gretel Rodríguez. And if you are looking for a great deal and outstanding service—Gretel Rodríguez.

    Yusniel Valdes

    3 months ago

  • Working with Gretel has been a fantastic experience. She took the time to explain all my options and made sure I felt confident in my policy. She’s very knowledgeable, attentive and friendly. Highly recommend.

    Ariana Lopez

    4 months ago

  • I always have an excellent experience with First Choice Insurance Agency Corp. The team is professional, responsive, and genuinely committed to helping me find the best coverage for my needs. They take the time to clearly explain my options, answer all of my questions, and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. I especially want to thank Gretal for her outstanding support. She went above and beyond to ensure everything was handled efficiently and kept me informed every step of the way. Her attention to detail, patience, and willingness to help truly made a difference. I highly recommend First Choice Insurance Agency Corp to anyone looking for reliable and trustworthy insurance services.

    Rene J

    4 months ago

  • Gretel Rodríguez as usual was a great agent. Thorough and well-informed. I highly recommend her. Francisco Rodriguez

    Fraancisco Rodriguez

    4 weeks ago

Ready to Get Protected?

Get a personalized quote in minutes. Our expert advisors are ready to help you find the perfect coverage for the right price.